College Soccer News’ annual All-American Team selections recognizes top performers throughout the country on both sides of the ball in 2019.
College Soccer News First Team All-America
 | Cal Jennings Senior Forward UCF Roswell, Georgia |
 | Robbie Robinson Junior Forward Clemson Camden, South Carolina |
 | Matthew Bentley Senior Forward Missouri State London, England |
 | Joe Bell Junior Midfielder Virginia Wanaka, New Zeland |
 | Manuel Ferriol Senior Midfielder James Madison Velencia, Spain |
 | Bruno Lapa Senior Midfielder Wake Forest Curitba, Brazil |
 | Blake Bodily Junior Midfielder Washington Eagle, Idaho |
 | Dylan Nealis Senior Defender Georgetown Massapequa, New York |
 | Eddie Munjoma Senior Defender SMU McKinney, Texas
|
 | Malik Mbaye Senior Defender Clemson Dakar, Senegal |
 | Tanner Beason Senior Defender Stanford Winston-Salem, North Carolina |
 | Colin Shutler Junior Goalkeeper Virginia Middleburg, Virginia |
College Soccer News Second Team All-America
 | Miguel Berry Senior Forward San Diego Poway, California |
 | Anders Engebretsen Senior Forward Saint Mary’s Oslo, Norway |
 | Garrett McLaughlin Senior Forward SMU Oklahoma City, Oklahoma |
 | Milan Iloski Junior Forward UCLA Escondido, California |
 | Jacob Montes Junior Midfielder Georgetown Lake Worth, Florida |
 | Aaron Molloy Senior Midfielder Penn State Dublin, Ireland |
 | Jesus Perez Senior Midfielder UIC Waukegan, Illinois |
 | Noah Billingsley Senior Defender UC Santa Barbara Wellington, New Zeland |
 | Josh Bauer Senior Defender New Hampshire Bedford, New Hampshire |
 | Henry Kessler Junior Defender Virginia New York, New York |
 | Kyle Hiebert Junior Defender Missouri State La Salle, Manitoba |
 | Andrew Thomas RS Sophomore Goalkeeper Stanford London, England |
College Soccer News Third Team All-America
 | Daryl Dike Sophomore Forward Virginia Edmond, Oklahoma |
 | Kimarni Smith Junior Forward Clemson Nottingham, England |
 | Milo Yosef RS Freshman Forward Marshall Aachen, Germany |
 | Thibaut Jacquel Junior Forward Campbell Sarrenbourg, France |
 | Aidan Megally Senior Midfielder Loyola Chicago Park Ridge, Illinois |
 | Lucas Rosa Junior Midfielder Saint Francis Atibaia, Brazil |
 | Gabriel Costa Sophomore Midfielder SMU Rio de Janeiro, Brazil |
 | Ethan Bartow Sophomore Defender Washington Woodinville, Washington |
 | Peder Kristiansen Senior Defender Rhode Island Lillestrom, Norway |
 | Aime Mabika RS Junior Defender Kentucky Lexington, Kentucky |
 | Jack Maher Sophomore Defender Indiana Caseyville, Illinois |
 | Elliot Panicco RS Senior Goalkeeper Charlotte Huntersville, North Carolina |
