College Soccer News 2017 Preseason All-America First Team
| Name | School | Class | Position | ||
 | Foster Langsdorf | Stanford | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Gordon Wild | Maryland | Junior | Forward |  |
 | Jon Gallagher | Notre Dame | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Albert Ruiz | FGCU | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Cam Lindley | North Carolina | Sophomore | Midfielder |  |
 | Paul Hoffmeister | Utah Valley | Senior | Midfielder |  |
 | Matias Pyysalo | UCF | Senior | Midfielder |  |
 | Grant Lillard | Indiana | Senior | Defender |  |
 | Tomas Hilliard-Arce | Stanford | Senior | Defender | |
 | Tim Kubel | Louisville | Senior | Defender |  |
 | Jeff Caldwell | Virginia | Senior | Goalkeeper |  |
College Soccer News 2017 Preseason All-America Second Team
| Name | School | Class | Position | ||
 | Marcelo Acuna | Virginia Tech | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Chris Mueller | Wisconsin | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Danny Musovski | UNLV | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Will Bagrou | Mercer | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Mohamed Thiaw | Louisville | Senior | Forward | |
 | Antonio Bustamante | William and Mary | Junior | Midfielder |  |
 | Ian McGrath | Evansville | Senior | Midfielder |  |
 | Handwalla Bwana | Washington | Sophomore | Midfielder |  |
 | Cory Brown | Xavier | Senior | Defender |  |
 | Grant Stoneman | Loyola Chicago | RS Junior | Defender |  |
 | Paul Christensen | Portland | Senior | Goalkeeper |  |
College Soccer News 2017 Preseason All-America Third Team
| Name | School | Class | Position | ||
 | Alfonso Pinheiro | Albany | Senior | Forward |  |
 | Abdou Mbacke Thiam | Connecticut | Junior | Forward |  |
 | Edward Opoku | Virginia | Junior | Forward | |
 | Ryan Sierakowski | Michigan State | Junior | Forward |  |
 | Tresor Mbuyu | Liberty | Junior | Forward |  |
 | Jon Bakero | Wake Forest | Senior | Midfielder |  |
 | Amar Sejdic | Maryland | Junior | Midfielder | |
 | Mauro Cichero | SMU | Senior | Midfielder |  |
 | Mark Jecewiz | Providence | RS Senior | Defender |  |
 | Wyatt Omsberg | Dartmouth | Senior | Defender |  |
 | Ben Lundgaard | Virginia Tech | Senior | Goalkeeper | |
