College Soccer News FIrst-Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Foster Langsdorf* | Senior | Forward | Stanford | Vancouver, Washington |
 | Jon Bakero | Senior | Forward | Wake Forest | Sitges, Spain |
 | Jon Gallagher* | Senior | Forward | Notre Dame | Dundalk, Ireland |
 | Christopher Mueller* | Senior | Forward | Wisconsin | Schaumburg, Illinois |
 | Cam Lindley | Sophomore | Midfielder | North Carolina | Carmel, Indiana |
 | Brandon Bye | Senior | Midfielder | Western Michigan | Portage, Michigan |
 | Mauro Cichero | Senior | Midfielder | SMU | Norman, Oklahoma |
 | Grant Lillard* | Senior | Defender | Indiana | Hindsdale, Illinois |
 | Tim Kubel* | Senior | Defender | Louisville | Stuttgart, Germany |
 | Thomas Hilliard-Arce | Senior | Defender | Stanford | Matthews, North Carolina |
 | Michael Nelson | RS Senior | Goalkeeper | SMU | Katy, Texas |
College Soccer News Second Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Santiago Patino | Junior | Forward | FIU | Orlando, Florida |
 | Alan Winn | Senior | Forward | North Carolina | Garland, Texas |
 | Brandon Guhl | Sophomore | Forward | Butler | Houston, Texas |
 | Mark Forrest | Junior | Forward | Lehigh | Douglassville, Pa. |
 | Tucker Bone | Junior | Midfielder | Air Force Academy | Granite Bay, California |
 | Antonio Bustamante | Junior | Midfielder | William and Mary | Springfield, Virginia |
 | Rafael Andrade Santos | Senior | Midfielder | VCU | Rio de Janiero, Brazil |
 | Jose Aguinaga | Senior | Midfielder | Rider | Madrid, Spain |
 | Andrew Gutman | Junior | Defender | Indiana | Hinsdale, Illinois |
 | Kevin Politz | Senior | Defender | Wake Forest | Morganville, New Jersey |
 | Jimmy Fiscus | Senior | Defender | Michigan State | Novi, Michigan |
 | Eric Dick | Senior | Goalkeeper | Butler | Carmel, Indiana |
College Soccer News Third Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Arthur Bosua | Senior | Forward | Columbia | Johannesburg, South Africa |
 | Janos Loebe | Junior | Forward | Fordham | Kierspe, Germany |
 | Danny Musovski | Senior | Forward | UNLV | Henderson, Nevada |
 | Paul Marie | Senior | Midfielder | FIU | Saint-Aubin-des-Bois, France |
 | Handwalla Bwana | Sophomore | Midfielder | Washington | Seattle, Washington |
 | Harry Cooksley | Senior | Midfielder | St. John's | London, England |
 | Eryk Williamson | Junior | Midfielder | Maryland | Alexandria, Virginia |
 | Faouzi Taieb | Sophomore | Defender | St. Francis Brooklyn | Marseille, France |
 | Wyatt Omsberg | Senior | Defender | Dartmouth | Scarborough, Maine |
 | Joao Moutinho | Freshman | Defender | Akron | Lisbon, Portugal |
 | Jordan Cano | Senior | Defender | SMU | Frisco, Texas |
 | Jimmy Hague | Junior | Goalkeeper | Michigan State | Walled Lake, Michigan |
*Repeat Selections
