The 2015 College Soccer News Men's All-America Team included a record twelve repeat selections. The Atlantic Coast Conference had a total of six selections while the Big East Conference had five selections. Clemson and Creighton each had a total of three selections.
College Soccer News 2015 Men's First Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Jordon Morris* | Junior | Forward | Stanford | Mercer Island, Washington |
 | Brandon Allen* | Senior | Forward | Georgetown | Old Bridge, New Jersey |
 | Fabian Herbers* | Junior | Forward | Creighton | Ahaus, Germany |
 | Timo Pitter* | Senior | Midfielder | Creighton | Oberschwarzach, Germany |
 | Adam Najem | Junior | Midfielder | Akron | Clifton, New Jersey |
 | Julian Buescher | Sophomore | Midfielder | Syracuse | Duelmen, Germany |
 | Jack Harrison | Freshman | Midfielder | Wake Forest | Bolton, England |
 | Brandon Vincent* | Senior | Defender | Stanford | Santa Clarita, California |
 | Joshua Yaro* | Junior | Defender | Georgetown | Santa Barbara, California |
 | Kyle Fisher | Senior | Defender | Clemson | Easley, South Carolina |
 | Callum Irving* | Senior | Goalkeeper | Kentucky | Vancouver, B.C. |
College Soccer News 2015 Men's Second Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Nick DePuy | Junior | Forward | UCSB | Irvine, California |
 | Kyle Parker* | Senior | Forward | Charlotte | Waxhaw, North Carolina |
 | T.J. Casner | Senior | Forward | Clemson | Irvine, California |
 | David Olsen | Sophomore | Forward | Seattle | Auburn, Washington |
 | Mauro Cichero | Sophomore | Midfielder | SMU | Norman, Oklahoma |
 | Tanner Thompson* | Junior | Midfielder | Indiana | Granite Bay, California |
 | Amass Amankona | Senior | Midfielder | Dayton | Kumasi, Ghana |
 | Kyle Bjornethun | Junior | Defender | Seattle | Snohomish, Washington |
 | Liam Doyle | Senior | Defender | Ohio State | Douglas, Isle of Man |
 | Jonathan Campbell | Senior | Defender | North Carolina | Greensboro, North Carolina |
 | Ryan Herman | Senior | Goalkeeper | Washington | Fall City, Washington |
College Soccer News 2015 Men's Third Team All-America
| Name | Class | Position | School | Hometown | |
 | Jason Wright | Sophomore | Forward | Rutgers | Kingston, Jamaica |
 | Danny Musovski | Sophomore | Forward | UNLV | Henderson, Nevada |
 | Guillermo Delgado* | Junior | Forward | Delaware | Tres Cantos, Spain |
 | Gordon Wild | Freshman | Forward | USC Upstate | Steimel, Germany |
 | Paul Clowes | Senior | Midfielder | Clemson | Cheshire, England |
 | Neco Brett* | Senior | Midfielder | Robert Morris | Kingston, Jamaica |
 | Richie Laryea | Sophomore | Midfielder | Akron | Toronto, Ontario |
 | Bradley Bourgeois | Senior | Defender | Tulsa | Cypress, Texas |
 | Reagan Dunk | Junior | Defender | Denver | Dallas, Texas |
 | Francis De Vries* | Junior | Defender | Saint Francis (Pa) | Christchurch, New Zealand |
 | Connor Sparrow | Senior | Goalkeeper | Creighton | Saint Louis, Missouri |
*repeat selection
