College Soccer News 2013 First Team All-Freshman
| Name | Position | School | |
 | Cyle Larin | Forward | Connecticut |
 | Tommy Thompson | Forward | Indiana |
 | Guillermo Delgado | Forward | Delaware |
 | Zeiko Lewis | Forward | Boston College |
 | Jordan Allen | Midfielder | Virginia |
 | Andrew Brody | Midfielder | Louisville |
 | Cristian Roldan | Midfielder | Washington |
 | Adam Najem | Midfielder | Akron |
 | Joshua Yaro | Defender | Georgetown |
 | Michael Amick | Defender | UCLA |
 | Zack Steffen | Goalkeeper | Maryland |
College Soccer News 2013 Second Team All-Freshman
| Name | Position | School | |
 | Emil Ekblom | Forward | Syracuse |
 | David Goldsmith | Forward | Butler |
 | Jordan Morris | Forward | Stanford |
 | Louis Bennett II | Midfielder | Marquette |
 | Lindo Mfeka | Midfielder | South Florida |
 | Ismaila Jome | Midfielder | UC Santa Barbara |
 | Ian Harkes | Midfielder | Wake Forest |
 | Eddie Sanchez | Midfielder | Portland |
 | Kwame Awuah | Defender | Connecticut |
 | Francis de Vries | Defender | St. Francis (PA) |
 | Tanner Vosvick | Defender | Army |
 | Steffen Kraus | Goalkeeper | George Mason |
College Soccer News 2013 Third Team All-Freshman
| Name | Position | School | |
 | Brody Huitema | Forward | Duke |
 | Max Hasenstab | Forward | Winthrop |
 | Bobby Edet | Forward | Furman |
 | Christopher Wehan | Midfielder | New Mexico |
 | Christian Flath | Midfielder | Rider |
 | Alex Muyl | Midfielder | Georgetown |
 | Alex Halis | Midfielder | Syracuse |
 | Russell Cicerone | Midfielder | Buffalo |
 | Conor Qualter | Defender | Central Connecticut |
 | Rylee Woods | Defender | Michigan |
 | Robert Sagel | Defender | Temple |
 | Andrew Putna | Goalkeeper | UIC |
