College Soccer News First Team All-Amerca
 | Levonte Johnson Forward Senior Syracuse University Brampton, Ontario |
 | Duncan McGuire Forward Junior Creighton University Omaha, Nebraska |
 | Ilijah Paul Forward Sophomore University of Washington Gilbert, Arizona |
 | Shakur Mohammed Forward Sophomore Duke University Kumasi, Ghana |
 | Knut Ahlander Midfielder Graduate Student SMU Notteroy, Norway |
 | Peter Stroud Midfielder Junior Duke University Chester, New Jersey |
 | J.C. Ngando Midfielder Sophomore UNCG Paris, France |
 | Keegan Hughes Defender Senior Stanford University Heath, Ohio |
 | Daniel Munie Defender Redshirt Senior Indiana University Maryland Heights, Missouri |
 | Luis Grassow Defender Senior University of Kentucky Munich, Germany |
 | Cole Jensen Goalkeeper Redshirt Junior Xavier University Council Bluffs, Iowa |
College Soccer News Second Team All-America
 | Stephen Afrifa Forward Senior FIU Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
 | Eythor Bjorgolfsson Forward Senior University of Kentucky Jessheim, Norway |
 | Stas Korzeniowski Forward Sophomore University of Pennsylvania Skillman, New Jersey |
 | Valentin Noel Midfielder Senior University of Pittsburgh Niort, France |
 | Eliot Goldthorp Midfielder Sophomore Hofstra Leeds, United Kingdom |
 | Alex Nagy Midfielder Fifth Year Senior University of Vermont Bow, New Hampshire |
 | Lucas Meek Midfielder Redshirt Senior University of Washington Mercer Island, Washington |
 | Noah Gulden Defender Graduate Student Lipscomb University Drammen, Norway |
 | Daniel Wu Defender Senior Georgetown University Cary, North Carolina |
 | Daniel Nimick Defender Senior Western Michigan University Harrogate, England |
 | Moise Bombito Defender Junior University of New Hampshire Montreal, Quebec |
 | Eliot Hamill Goalkeeper Graduate Student Duke University Scarsdale, New York |
College Soccer News Third Team All-America
 | MD Myers Forward Senior Rutgers University Delran, New Jersey |
 | Milo Yosef Forward Redshirt Senior Marshal University Aachen, Germany |
 | Finn Ballard McBride Forward Junior UCSB Sydney, Australia |
 | Nathan Opoku Forward Sophomore Syracuse University Accra, Ghana |
 | Emeka Eneli Midfielder Fifth Year Senior Cornell University Dublin, Ohio |
 | Brandon Cambridge Midfielder Sophomore Portland Surrey, B.C. |
 | Dyson Clapier Midfielder Sophomore Akron Layton, Utah |
 | Yannick Bright Midfielder Junior University of New Hampshire Milan, Italy |
 | Mariano Fazio Defender Senior University of Tulsa Sevilla, Spain |
 | Leo Burney Defender Sophomore University of Pennsylvania Seattle, Washington |
 | Nick Richardson Defender Redshirt Senior University of Maryland Baltimore, Maryland |
 | Sam Fowler Goalkeeper Junior University of Washington Issaquah, Washington |
