College Soccer News First Team All-America
 | Charlie Sharp Senior Forward Western Michigan Brighton, Michigan |
 | Marcus Caldeira Sophomore Forward West Virginia Mississauga, Ontario, Canada |
 | Matthew Bell Junior Forward Marshall Kingston, Jamaica |
 | Jason Shokalook Junior Forward Akron Erie, Pennsylvania |
 | Yannick Bright Senior Midfielder New Hampshire Milan, Italy |
 | Eliot Goldthorp Junior Midfielder Hofstra Leeds, United Kingdom |
 | Ousmane Sylla Senior Midfielder Clemson Dakar, Senegal |
 | Kevin Bonilla Junior Defender Portland Dallas, Texas |
 | Garrison Tubbs Senior Defender Wake Forest Brunswick, Georgia |
 | Kenny Nielsen Senior Defender Georgetown Irvine, California |
 | Bryan Dowd Senior Goalkeeper Notre Dame Willow Springs, Illinois |
College Soccer News Second TEam All-America
 | Tyrese Spicer Redshirt Junior Forward Lipscomb Trincity, Trinidad and Tobago |
 | Ryan Carmichael Senior Forward Hofstra Armagh, Northern Ireland |
 | Peter Mangione Senior Forward Penn State Hunt Valley, Maryland |
 | Logan Farrington Senior Forward Oregon State Racine, Wisconsin |
 | Yutaro Tsukada Senior Forward West Virginia Tokyo, Japan |
 | Sam Bassett Junior Midfielder Denver Littleton, Colorado |
 | Zach Bohane Sophomore Midfielder Stanford Monte Sereno, California |
 | Mason Tunbridge Redshirt Senior Midfielder San Diego London, England |
 | Jaylen Shannon Graduate Student Defender Western Michigan St. Joseph, Michigan |
 | Morris Duggan Graduate Student Defender Marshall Munich, Germany |
 | Mads Westergren Junior Defender SMU Solroed Strand, Denmark |
 | Kiergan Sargeant Junior Defender Georgetown League City, Texas |
 | Cole Johnson Senior Goalkeeper SMU Phoenix, Arizona |
College Soccer News Third Team All-America
 | Alec Hughes Senior Forward Massachusetts Glastonbury, Connecticut |
 | Taylor Calheira Senior Forward UMBC Towson, Maryland |
 | Samuel Sarver Junior Forward Indiana Chesterland, Ohio |
 | Dylan Sing Graduate Student Forward Western Michigan Berrien Center, Michigan |
 | Jelldrik Dallman Graduate Student Forward SMU Kuhstedt, Germany |
 | James Morris Senior Foreard Seattle Doncaster, England |
 | David Jackson Senior Midfielder Navy Cypress, Texas |
 | Tucker Lepley Redshirt Junior Midfielder UCLA Charlotte, North Carolina |
 | Jack Denton Senior Midfielder Missouri State London, England |
 | Jeorgio Kocevski Senior Midfielder Syracuse Liverpool, New York |
 | Griffin Roach Senior Defender Boston University Canton, Massachusetts |
 | Finn McRobb Senior Defender High Point University Glasgow, Scotland |
 | Joseba Incera Graduate Student Goalkeeper New Hampshire Santurtzi, Spain |
