By Andrew Gagis | @andrewgagis
It is now that time of year when teams across the country are turning their attention to the NCAA Tournament.
Today, the NCAA will reveal the brackets for the Division I men’s and women’s soccer tournaments. Although, what if I told you winning 15 games doesn’t guarantee a spot in the NCAA soccer tournament? Neither does finishing near the top of your conference.
What goes into deciding which teams make the tournament, and which ones are left out?
Automatic Bids and At-Large Selections
There are two ways teams can earn a spot in the NCAA Tournament. That is through an automatic bid by winning your conference championship or being an at-large selection, meaning a team who did not win their conference championship but still qualified.
The men’s tournament features 48 teams, with 23 automatic bids and 25 at-large spots. On the women’s side, 64 teams compete, with 31 automatic bids and 33 at-large selections.
Automatic bids are awarded to conference champions which gives teams a chance to earn their way into the NCAA Tournament without having to rely on the selection committee.
For teams that don’t secure an automatic bid, things become a little more complicated.
Those teams must rely on several different factors from throughout the season, which the NCAA selection committee evaluates before deciding who receives the remaining tournament spots.
What Does the Selection Committee Look At?
A team’s win-loss record matters, but it doesn’t tell the whole story.
One of the biggest factors in the selection process is the Rating Percentage Index (RPI). This ranking system takes into account a team’s winning percentage, its opponents’ winning percentages, and the records of those opponents’ opponents.
In other words, the NCAA isn’t just looking at how many games a team won. It also considers who those wins came against.
According to NCAA’s Division I Men’s Soccer Prechampionship Manual, “The following criteria shall be employed by a governing sports committee in selecting participants for NCAA championships competition: Won-lost record, Strength of schedule, and Eligibility/availability of student-athletes for NCAA championships.”
Although the men’s and women’s selection processes are similar, there are some differences in how the committees evaluate teams.
The men’s committee considers its published selection criteria without a required order of importance. The women’s committee separates its evaluation factors into primary and secondary criteria, with the Kevin Pauga Index (KPI) included among its secondary measurements.
These factors help the committees compare teams that may have played completely different schedules.
Why Strength of Schedule Matters
One of the more interesting parts of the selection process is how the NCAA compares teams from different conferences.
A team from a smaller conference could finish with a 15-3 record, while a team from a stronger conference might finish 10-6. You may think the 15-win team has the better résumé, however, the 10-win team may have faced tougher competition throughout the season and picked up wins against nationally ranked opponents.
That’s where strength of schedule becomes important.
Programs in smaller conferences do not get the same amount of opportunities to play highly ranked opponents. Even with an impressive record, those teams may find themselves competing for an at-large spot against programs that have played tougher schedules.
This is one reason conference tournaments carry so much weight. Winning an automatic bid takes the decision out of the selection committee’s hands.
According to The Observer in May 2026, Notre Dame men’s soccer head coach Chad Riley reflected on the uncertainty surrounding his team’s NCAA Tournament selection. “We felt good about it because we had some good wins and a strong schedule, but at the same time, it certainly wasn’t a lock.”
Riley’s comments highlight how even teams with quality wins and difficult schedules can be uncertain about their tournament chances heading into Selection Monday.
What Happens After the Teams Are Selected?
Once the automatic bids have been decided, the selection committees fill the remaining spots and finalize the brackets.
The men’s tournament has 48 teams, with the top 16 seeded teams receiving a first-round bye. The other 32 teams compete in the opening round for a chance to advance.
The women’s tournament follows a 64-team format, meaning every team begins play in the first round.
For teams sitting on the bubble, Selection Monday can be a nerve-racking experience, creating a lot of controversy from fans. A strong regular season doesn’t always guarantee a tournament appearance, especially when several teams are competing for a limited number of at-large spots.
With the brackets set to be announced later today, teams across the country will soon find out whether they’ve done enough to keep their seasons alive.
